{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "method": "gapo",
  "seeds": [
    42,
    43,
    44
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "algorithm": "gapo",
      "dataset": "arithmetic-smoke",
      "baseline": {
        "accuracy": 0.21875,
        "mean_reward": 0.37543359369622153,
        "entropy": 1.7917594692220566,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.0
      },
      "final": {
        "accuracy": 0.421875,
        "mean_reward": 0.5446313590076556,
        "entropy": 1.7818994110946482,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.009860058127406436
      },
      "training": {
        "steps": 100,
        "learning_rate": 0.08,
        "group_size": 4,
        "train_examples": 128,
        "validation_examples": 64,
        "data_source": "deterministic arithmetic smoke suite",
        "teacher_cache_entries": 0,
        "teacher_prefill_calls": 0,
        "online_teacher_calls": 0,
        "drift_events": 0,
        "critic_updates": 0,
        "rollout_policy_refreshes": 6,
        "last_diagnostics": {
          "group_correct_count": 1.0,
          "adaptive_upper_clip": 0.28,
          "scarce_correct_headroom": 0.08000000000000002,
          "clipped_fraction": 0.25,
          "loss": 0.047725027927304195,
          "policy_entropy": 1.778396792537984
        },
        "fidelity": "mechanism reproduction on a candidate-policy model"
      },
      "history": [
        {
          "step": 1.0,
          "loss": 2.7755575615628914e-17,
          "accuracy": 0.25,
          "mean_reward": 0.40145623576137734,
          "entropy": 1.7917502038535345,
          "kl_from_reference": 9.265368521198551e-06
        },
        {
          "step": 10.0,
          "loss": 0.0010080296396685062,
          "accuracy": 0.453125,
          "mean_reward": 0.5705603277836471,
          "entropy": 1.7917219786690615,
          "kl_from_reference": 3.74905529937146e-05
        },
        {
          "step": 20.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.3125,
          "mean_reward": 0.4582250196028919,
          "entropy": 1.791024627555118,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0007348416669370428
        },
        {
          "step": 30.0,
          "loss": 0.0015943453488787562,
          "accuracy": 0.40625,
          "mean_reward": 0.5316160715658655,
          "entropy": 1.7907521970127875,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.001007272209267382
        },
        {
          "step": 40.0,
          "loss": 0.005001013003694585,
          "accuracy": 0.65625,
          "mean_reward": 0.7310853686902267,
          "entropy": 1.7905930532952772,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0011664159267776972
        },
        {
          "step": 50.0,
          "loss": 0.011933054587197428,
          "accuracy": 0.59375,
          "mean_reward": 0.6787449246376994,
          "entropy": 1.78962262706327,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0021368421587853476
        },
        {
          "step": 60.0,
          "loss": 0.021180725438946835,
          "accuracy": 0.453125,
          "mean_reward": 0.5698550772502142,
          "entropy": 1.788414829383819,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0033446398382354146
        },
        {
          "step": 70.0,
          "loss": 0.019522481362261368,
          "accuracy": 0.453125,
          "mean_reward": 0.5698550772502142,
          "entropy": 1.7872104754517228,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.004548993770332441
        },
        {
          "step": 80.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.59375,
          "mean_reward": 0.6787449246376994,
          "entropy": 1.7869127852837388,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.00484668393831575
        },
        {
          "step": 90.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.46875,
          "mean_reward": 0.5809417921744868,
          "entropy": 1.784591284296789,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0071681849252662735
        },
        {
          "step": 100.0,
          "loss": 0.047725027927304195,
          "accuracy": 0.421875,
          "mean_reward": 0.5446313590076556,
          "entropy": 1.7818994110946482,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.009860058127406436
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "algorithm": "gapo",
      "dataset": "arithmetic-smoke",
      "baseline": {
        "accuracy": 0.09375,
        "mean_reward": 0.29445010883453737,
        "entropy": 1.7917594692220566,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.0
      },
      "final": {
        "accuracy": 0.421875,
        "mean_reward": 0.5684269316552883,
        "entropy": 1.7813570960728136,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.010402373149241098
      },
      "training": {
        "steps": 100,
        "learning_rate": 0.08,
        "group_size": 4,
        "train_examples": 128,
        "validation_examples": 64,
        "data_source": "deterministic arithmetic smoke suite",
        "teacher_cache_entries": 0,
        "teacher_prefill_calls": 0,
        "online_teacher_calls": 0,
        "drift_events": 0,
        "critic_updates": 0,
        "rollout_policy_refreshes": 6,
        "last_diagnostics": {
          "group_correct_count": 1.0,
          "adaptive_upper_clip": 0.28,
          "scarce_correct_headroom": 0.08000000000000002,
          "clipped_fraction": 0.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "policy_entropy": 1.7860392050143439
        },
        "fidelity": "mechanism reproduction on a candidate-policy model"
      },
      "history": [
        {
          "step": 1.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.09375,
          "mean_reward": 0.29445010883453737,
          "entropy": 1.7917594692220566,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0
        },
        {
          "step": 10.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.28125,
          "mean_reward": 0.45588093240027033,
          "entropy": 1.7916221588616612,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.00013731036039362705
        },
        {
          "step": 20.0,
          "loss": 0.00622572093825681,
          "accuracy": 0.625,
          "mean_reward": 0.7041525998782429,
          "entropy": 1.7914661941068182,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0002932751152366793
        },
        {
          "step": 30.0,
          "loss": 0.010825288310462367,
          "accuracy": 0.6875,
          "mean_reward": 0.755612167727089,
          "entropy": 1.7911441711043474,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0006152981177076402
        },
        {
          "step": 40.0,
          "loss": 0.006694653888866767,
          "accuracy": 0.59375,
          "mean_reward": 0.6759060138675912,
          "entropy": 1.7900368564346614,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0017226127873937649
        },
        {
          "step": 50.0,
          "loss": 0.0036250672414080976,
          "accuracy": 0.65625,
          "mean_reward": 0.7319297656410946,
          "entropy": 1.7896084942032227,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.002150975018831545
        },
        {
          "step": 60.0,
          "loss": 0.012882986915348685,
          "accuracy": 0.65625,
          "mean_reward": 0.7334598692607528,
          "entropy": 1.7890253346898644,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0027341345321896505
        },
        {
          "step": 70.0,
          "loss": 0.010369872280361014,
          "accuracy": 0.640625,
          "mean_reward": 0.7157546672346244,
          "entropy": 1.787622515456633,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.004136953765422334
        },
        {
          "step": 80.0,
          "loss": 0.013705704194065915,
          "accuracy": 0.609375,
          "mean_reward": 0.6899876322479375,
          "entropy": 1.7867685069636003,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.004990962258454614
        },
        {
          "step": 90.0,
          "loss": 0.01657964066472417,
          "accuracy": 0.671875,
          "mean_reward": 0.7471978292790252,
          "entropy": 1.7851990426569229,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.006560426565131982
        },
        {
          "step": 100.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.421875,
          "mean_reward": 0.5684269316552883,
          "entropy": 1.7813570960728136,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.010402373149241098
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "algorithm": "gapo",
      "dataset": "arithmetic-smoke",
      "baseline": {
        "accuracy": 0.125,
        "mean_reward": 0.3084124873907742,
        "entropy": 1.7917594692220566,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.0
      },
      "final": {
        "accuracy": 0.578125,
        "mean_reward": 0.6617063289334468,
        "entropy": 1.7818407903433553,
        "kl_from_reference": 0.009918678878699612
      },
      "training": {
        "steps": 100,
        "learning_rate": 0.08,
        "group_size": 4,
        "train_examples": 128,
        "validation_examples": 64,
        "data_source": "deterministic arithmetic smoke suite",
        "teacher_cache_entries": 0,
        "teacher_prefill_calls": 0,
        "online_teacher_calls": 0,
        "drift_events": 0,
        "critic_updates": 0,
        "rollout_policy_refreshes": 6,
        "last_diagnostics": {
          "group_correct_count": 1.0,
          "adaptive_upper_clip": 0.28,
          "scarce_correct_headroom": 0.08000000000000002,
          "clipped_fraction": 0.0,
          "loss": 0.021443152208688865,
          "policy_entropy": 1.7793725888812388
        },
        "fidelity": "mechanism reproduction on a candidate-policy model"
      },
      "history": [
        {
          "step": 1.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.125,
          "mean_reward": 0.3084124873907742,
          "entropy": 1.7917594692220566,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0
        },
        {
          "step": 10.0,
          "loss": 0.0037376832650311553,
          "accuracy": 0.515625,
          "mean_reward": 0.6118263275298665,
          "entropy": 1.7915745317275111,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.00018493749454402496
        },
        {
          "step": 20.0,
          "loss": 0.00044555398350781816,
          "accuracy": 0.578125,
          "mean_reward": 0.6617063289334468,
          "entropy": 1.7914575141164006,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.00030195510565422605
        },
        {
          "step": 30.0,
          "loss": 0.013255700305160434,
          "accuracy": 0.515625,
          "mean_reward": 0.6129497685619247,
          "entropy": 1.7906569287709184,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0011025404511367921
        },
        {
          "step": 40.0,
          "loss": -0.0,
          "accuracy": 0.515625,
          "mean_reward": 0.6129497685619247,
          "entropy": 1.7898804050342623,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.0018790641877926967
        },
        {
          "step": 50.0,
          "loss": 0.011055917452263975,
          "accuracy": 0.5625,
          "mean_reward": 0.6491769737864237,
          "entropy": 1.7888336288181033,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.002925840403951479
        },
        {
          "step": 60.0,
          "loss": 0.026394508926111643,
          "accuracy": 0.546875,
          "mean_reward": 0.6367268193306765,
          "entropy": 1.7870376132965966,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.004721855925458081
        },
        {
          "step": 70.0,
          "loss": 0.022664222905078538,
          "accuracy": 0.515625,
          "mean_reward": 0.6138373723657503,
          "entropy": 1.7847664915522377,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.006992977669817275
        },
        {
          "step": 80.0,
          "loss": 0.043801149649664015,
          "accuracy": 0.546875,
          "mean_reward": 0.6367268193306765,
          "entropy": 1.7834052201578179,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.008354249064237252
        },
        {
          "step": 90.0,
          "loss": -0.004637127066895508,
          "accuracy": 0.578125,
          "mean_reward": 0.663137529436808,
          "entropy": 1.7829390319930323,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.008820437229022786
        },
        {
          "step": 100.0,
          "loss": 0.021443152208688865,
          "accuracy": 0.578125,
          "mean_reward": 0.6617063289334468,
          "entropy": 1.7818407903433553,
          "kl_from_reference": 0.009918678878699612
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "manifest_ref": "post-training:arithmetic-smoke-seeds42-44",
  "evaluation_protocol": {
    "tier": "l1_mechanism",
    "seeds": [
      42,
      43,
      44
    ],
    "formal_comparison": true,
    "claim_policy": "formal multi-seed comparison"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "artifact_path": "docs/post-training/2609.00444-gapo/metrics/arithmetic-smoke-seeds42-44.json",
    "dataset_fingerprint": "not recorded in historical artifact"
  }
}