{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "adapter_key": "upturn",
  "manifest_ref": "reproduction:upturn",
  "method": "upturn",
  "measured_locally": true,
  "diagnostic_only": true,
  "promotion_eligible": false,
  "not_gpu_receipt": true,
  "whole_method_gpu_validation_passed": false,
  "execution_complete": true,
  "all_seed_mechanism_passed": false,
  "dataset": {
    "verified": true,
    "test_read": false,
    "source_id": "openai/grade-school-math",
    "source_revision": "3101c7d5072418e28b9008a6636bde82a006892c",
    "source_sha256": "17f347dc51477c50d4efb83959dbb7c56297aba886e5544ee2aaed3024813465",
    "partition_sha256": {
      "train": "6b8672439c8cf6f6b6e65bf5f0e515fbf4c497c9066eefb62a6a6a61ced158e3",
      "validation": "2cf1119ad7b2e31e825274487ef32c073e03a8ed44f08ecd3e0366c1f40ebdb7"
    },
    "partition": "normalized-question sha256 unsigned-prefix / 2^64 < 0.1 validation"
  },
  "checkpoint": {
    "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct",
    "revision": "bb46c15ee4bb56c5b63245ef50fd7637234d6f75",
    "verified_mirror": {
      "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct",
      "revision": "bb46c15ee4bb56c5b63245ef50fd7637234d6f75",
      "file_sha256": {
        "config.json": "7463bb0ea78315365e6c6b74de4e73bbcc8359dfb0c5a737584e077d42c0b03c",
        "generation_config.json": "3a8f9087e486054c8a4a08dae2e5a3ba62e23da212b5b8c08bc42cb983c3459f",
        "merges.txt": "599bab54075088774b1733fde865d5bd747cbcc7a547c5bc12610e874e26f5e3",
        "model-00001-of-00004.safetensors": "a1333e6293854747c481288ea83b348226af178dd565c49b6f9495ba1966aba7",
        "model-00002-of-00004.safetensors": "f5d25a2772cb825164a2a2c0fb6d51a87e282abf21e4dd75bc5cfb3cd0ea6185",
        "model-00003-of-00004.safetensors": "8efdec4c1bc12317ae1a38dc42b595ce777738a64deea3fcb8a0a91381bcdfd5",
        "model-00004-of-00004.safetensors": "1a72d403cdf0c1ec3cb7f289f17b394a01e64394c2e9b3c0f94dbce3faf879bd",
        "model.safetensors.index.json": "624bf7c47cd12468fdc16e38a47cf4f19e0415b859a223ba3c027eed2f0e1028",
        "tokenizer.json": "c0382117ea329cdf097041132f6d735924b697924d6f6fc3945713e96ce87539",
        "tokenizer_config.json": "5b5d4f65d0acd3b2d56a35b56d374a36cbc1c8fa5cf3b3febbbfabf22f359583",
        "vocab.json": "ca10d7e9fb3ed18575dd1e277a2579c16d108e32f27439684afa0e10b1440910"
      }
    }
  },
  "evaluation_protocol": {
    "tier": "l1_mechanism",
    "formal_comparison": false,
    "promotion_eligible": false,
    "test_used_for_selection": false,
    "assessment_is_training_before_after": false,
    "matched_actual_compute": false,
    "claim_policy": "execution-complete cohort including failed44, not accepted three-seed mechanism or stable gain",
    "seeds": [
      44
    ]
  },
  "provenance": {
    "code_commit": "51b4718a76da286b4111c6fc7d8e003d436def72",
    "executed_source_sha256": {
      "scripts/prepare_soar_catalog_qa.py": "483a4eb3d9932d31046888c165c06590e67c6df5575a5b2afd4e302145f445e7",
      "scripts/run_oct13_post_training.py": "916b3b9a0eaeeaf30bad811376fa05305011754c922bb368a0f39833aad07ffa",
      "src/auto_research/oct12_public_sources.py": "4e1150cbe4ea975819c244267180f853c83c4ad4c2c27f9e0ce95cc16793e093",
      "src/auto_research/post_training/oct10_checkpoint.py": "247f1f97a3ca701277f241ec81d99296f0ea82e1db8f68006fcd7bfdc661cd74",
      "src/auto_research/post_training/oct13_common.py": "739f276633d74a85ba790e4d6df25504bce89950c40867ed57302cde03f1ada9",
      "src/auto_research/post_training/proximal_checkpoint.py": "5307a54204720e5407d2cd0435b654ae0e594f30c85cdf07d55d4e90612a1397",
      "src/auto_research/post_training/response_policy.py": "e380a5b4d1d53974b973b72b7d9ad6328129dc8c9bae4d233f6c1cbdf8508bf7",
      "src/auto_research/public_holdout.py": "033d9c1fd112accf5ac79573b99d9f31cffc646bcab6911cf3e49459fa003b46",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/gppo_framework/__init__.py": "7fe8cab42fef9f32b9653dfb5f54f03182de0753de2c9e5b359d124d7cd763d8",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/gppo_framework/adapter.py": "a7f4ee792a8ded3daeeb183cbca5c99de63c1b7d3cb195f5bedd5289cb0e0260",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/gppo_framework/objective.py": "0f8fbb2ad397b04a70466dde4e939f4d094ad7e7df07cfbba59f4a6ca5d05dd0",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/gppo_framework/paper.yaml": "a023ee98bbd078077b2708122973d27a98085848be816ce461b7d4291aca8e1f",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/grpo_difficulty_curriculum/__init__.py": "d09d8d7e0e6f5bcec9979241eed06a1d2a6ac8f3fb7a25f49e0df55be0071acb",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/grpo_difficulty_curriculum/adapter.py": "bbd3e964dc035ea4bbd999a581ea07eccabd986b6456774b21a4c24092cbdfbe",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/grpo_difficulty_curriculum/algorithm.py": "4131e39279d30c0748b14f611ab657b3fea76147a7c164aea2883c62bde75785",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/grpo_difficulty_curriculum/checkpoint.py": "d03a7d2db0a19b469fe5429ddce634b02d8cbd0eeed8d09bef0afc51c1d7ac70",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/grpo_difficulty_curriculum/paper.yaml": "0b4dd86c85907b732df9380a4bd1bbc17785c09c184d5be2793ac37f63768c16",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/magicbeanstalk/__init__.py": "8dd207ea37a89dfa34f87b02eb4a2fd26472895678d1362a7e5b59dad5cda616",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/magicbeanstalk/adapter.py": "319b6503de342feee49fb6446b7bbdeb117f7dc0dd7b79ed1c3bd34cce1ce73f",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/magicbeanstalk/algorithm.py": "78a68baad5b98b402fb87702ab50d5e01000f41250111604b84321e6c3e4900f",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/magicbeanstalk/checkpoint.py": "24dd8eb1979c04c2128919533f83fb347d9b40ab52184f7b1b9b3644512e9eae",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/magicbeanstalk/paper.yaml": "e9c5619918b4d72d776008aba3fa95d50ba6ebe99afab729ba9e6dfe82fac06e",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/progressive_contraction/__init__.py": "e50fe46d888e0a0b11b7d4d6d8f3224ae5940394f8ba8396fc5afb1cd38a4d53",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/progressive_contraction/adapter.py": "06f23b5c795f7222f76dee9beaa8164f460eb5183e18c6d374bff011737235dd",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/progressive_contraction/algorithm.py": "ba077b8c52a8d10e268a4e5c85770b9cebcb12415f9b2aaf7b9500e1303ca4b1",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/progressive_contraction/checkpoint.py": "67fa44814d613d3838716fea68476217d608af14f23a051e32a916b72538e7ec",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/progressive_contraction/paper.yaml": "1beccb702ce7a33b196b1fcc6bab13cdc32fc48952d247565d54e8ce830860c2",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/soar/__init__.py": "3d87d1189d7037e32c1e2cb0c249d13609c5af3d7062a19904590ba7923c799a",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/soar/adapter.py": "8fbbe8f8fe54b9f014ccc26a75b01e72b73b95e2b03cc379c5b5db4b63c9b31e",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/soar/algorithm.py": "9b7068d9774d1c93800c512a04b9ba4d0ee98fc13d308e5ac0970299c8bb2485",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/soar/checkpoint.py": "43a83930af442dc3610d61becd06b38ca3c921131ed417837d3d7e11aa672708",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/soar/paper.yaml": "2f756cab9f7fefd4613bb69971fd8252c2b9ad451fa5c5eff5d03fa063d91521",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/__init__.py": "8db07736f0336ed7f39502ae2953bdae76658942542cacbe4b6b2c1fd0abe094",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/adapter.py": "2f8bf4773e8f40c0eabe777fbd1e1aa6d372a7b05501404c3e3f7b2d54987524",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/algorithm.py": "dc7fe3eae619ff69ec51c47826f89471f00be564ea4e6730e12726a060ba7e2f",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/checkpoint.py": "95755e0604f563a5c96f92e9de9069befe3e1274d31c224a43ca20d71f756b09",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/environment.py": "0e9564f9ec540985eb010b1e70f46938acc1bd946041b518d6579253762080e1",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/state_opd/paper.yaml": "86c75255f1c416611a181c26359e9f5d9865caaea5266ca7b13dd8a183b906cc",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/synthself/__init__.py": "474bb75e10b95afe6faec1f3631beab2f17f9a43013d3d29e79b7d4b36e06031",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/synthself/adapter.py": "db4c08e1ccc2acfc28d19fc72acfa39b0a0dce096bbc430bafe9b21dbb72cddd",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/synthself/algorithm.py": "1e7ea1ff65d3ba0ece1af889022c19f7147f51d10fb8196ab8f9fa2e18604b95",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/synthself/checkpoint.py": "dbcf9f222094c197e0392f82191a0ae6551c6573ee54a9eee8c7d37553472981",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/synthself/paper.yaml": "464d06e9cdd535ab61743fdba6641ae2eac4c8345fad27748c63e620544074c7",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/tapo_trajectory/__init__.py": "a0dd8d4825b91dd076b71bdd3a3eccb0638ba4bf0240fe9da76d61a7290f69c6",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/tapo_trajectory/adapter.py": "c01b75bf7853546caa2d517dd5f9c9faf739537b95207b8f1fd28adcdd5aafa7",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/tapo_trajectory/objective.py": "49ab02ac758251acde90091a82b22576449d294a1f25cc3144ff1addd1132ae2",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/tapo_trajectory/paper.yaml": "493e59ec67f96ee37ffecf6694dd5c4d8555849b8f756ccb63644da90bbb48d6",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/upturn/__init__.py": "1e9793e9ea85e94144f7eac8fa141567d7f964438fa628788b668358154e196e",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/upturn/adapter.py": "72e5da3cb70856944d0c9a25376f73d4a1d9f16213efd43e19b3acf2a584afc2",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/upturn/algorithm.py": "421abd06cc492c39cf72e9b15c7f85c01e85fae0a7c26fb3053fbd19bc4897a4",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/upturn/checkpoint.py": "fbcb7c830cf53d3130cfc06621f3178516aa72c7a939f4f765c3c7864b383787",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/upturn/paper.yaml": "a1e335526f895b54e325331dc8354330f4a2d44f5f8c9c2a37f76ef2f7d589bc",
      "scripts/diagnose_oct14_post_training.py": "2a15d720a4f84bd1e415a4f0653c589c9716d526d4842acd5df728fd3575ca5b"
    },
    "execution_config_sha256": "506dce6568921b9c8fa75d969267537f9bb5c5c5b093a77b283616a2246524c5",
    "dataset_fingerprint": "69efc634f51a589335fcdea85238bf3218653a94de2ba2604a64056960547dab",
    "artifact_path": "docs/reproductions/2610.13672-upturn/metrics/public-a100-complete-failed-seed44.json",
    "raw_result_sha256": "cdf14bdcf8e8dd49653a7714fbca0d9e9e61fa857f73316d6faa42e5289d454e"
  },
  "limitations": [
    "44 has only entropy-driven parameter updates and no rescue signal; it cannot pass mechanism validation.",
    "42/43 passed individually; existing seed42 GPU receipt remains source-bound, but no three-seed passed receipt is issued.",
    "Four validation cases and matched maximum allowances are not equal realized generation pools or formal capability evidence.",
    "All negative metrics are retained; no retry, sample expansion, threshold change or forced advantage."
  ],
  "seeds": [
    44
  ],
  "seed_results": [
    {
      "seed": 44,
      "diagnostic_only": true,
      "device": "cuda",
      "mechanism_passed": false,
      "result": {
        "method": "upturn",
        "seed": 44,
        "device": "cuda",
        "diagnostic_only": true,
        "promotion_eligible": false,
        "evaluation_tier": "l1_mechanism",
        "dataset": {
          "verified": true,
          "test_read": false,
          "source_id": "openai/grade-school-math",
          "source_revision": "3101c7d5072418e28b9008a6636bde82a006892c",
          "source_sha256": "17f347dc51477c50d4efb83959dbb7c56297aba886e5544ee2aaed3024813465",
          "partition_sha256": {
            "train": "6b8672439c8cf6f6b6e65bf5f0e515fbf4c497c9066eefb62a6a6a61ced158e3",
            "validation": "2cf1119ad7b2e31e825274487ef32c073e03a8ed44f08ecd3e0366c1f40ebdb7"
          },
          "partition": "normalized-question sha256 unsigned-prefix / 2^64 < 0.1 validation"
        },
        "checkpoint": {
          "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct",
          "revision": "bb46c15ee4bb56c5b63245ef50fd7637234d6f75",
          "verified_mirror": {
            "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct",
            "revision": "bb46c15ee4bb56c5b63245ef50fd7637234d6f75",
            "file_sha256": {
              "config.json": "7463bb0ea78315365e6c6b74de4e73bbcc8359dfb0c5a737584e077d42c0b03c",
              "generation_config.json": "3a8f9087e486054c8a4a08dae2e5a3ba62e23da212b5b8c08bc42cb983c3459f",
              "merges.txt": "599bab54075088774b1733fde865d5bd747cbcc7a547c5bc12610e874e26f5e3",
              "model-00001-of-00004.safetensors": "a1333e6293854747c481288ea83b348226af178dd565c49b6f9495ba1966aba7",
              "model-00002-of-00004.safetensors": "f5d25a2772cb825164a2a2c0fb6d51a87e282abf21e4dd75bc5cfb3cd0ea6185",
              "model-00003-of-00004.safetensors": "8efdec4c1bc12317ae1a38dc42b595ce777738a64deea3fcb8a0a91381bcdfd5",
              "model-00004-of-00004.safetensors": "1a72d403cdf0c1ec3cb7f289f17b394a01e64394c2e9b3c0f94dbce3faf879bd",
              "model.safetensors.index.json": "624bf7c47cd12468fdc16e38a47cf4f19e0415b859a223ba3c027eed2f0e1028",
              "tokenizer.json": "c0382117ea329cdf097041132f6d735924b697924d6f6fc3945713e96ce87539",
              "tokenizer_config.json": "5b5d4f65d0acd3b2d56a35b56d374a36cbc1c8fa5cf3b3febbbfabf22f359583",
              "vocab.json": "ca10d7e9fb3ed18575dd1e277a2579c16d108e32f27439684afa0e10b1440910"
            }
          }
        },
        "baseline": {
          "avg_accuracy": 0.6875,
          "pass_rate": 1.0,
          "examples": 4
        },
        "method_metrics": {
          "avg_accuracy": 0.625,
          "pass_rate": 0.75,
          "examples": 4
        },
        "training": [
          {
            "step": 1,
            "cuts": [
              23,
              153,
              83
            ],
            "loss": -0.001096704276278615,
            "gradient_l2_norm": 0.000165349745657295,
            "optimizer_update_executed": true,
            "advantages": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "rescue_rewards": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "entropy": 1.0967042446136475,
            "nonzero_rescue_advantage": false
          },
          {
            "step": 2,
            "cuts": [
              82,
              253,
              35
            ],
            "loss": -0.0010908674448728561,
            "gradient_l2_norm": 0.00031461796606890857,
            "optimizer_update_executed": true,
            "advantages": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "rescue_rewards": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "entropy": 1.0908674001693726,
            "nonzero_rescue_advantage": false
          }
        ],
        "cost": {
          "generation_calls": {
            "frozen_reasoner_training": 8,
            "position_rescue_training": 6,
            "evaluation_originals": 4,
            "matched_base_extra": 4
          },
          "generated_tokens": {
            "frozen_reasoner_training": 7662,
            "position_rescue_training": 1298,
            "evaluation_originals": 2390,
            "matched_base_extra": 2383
          },
          "scored_response_tokens": {},
          "frozen_encoder_forward_calls": 40,
          "frozen_encoder_input_tokens_including_prompt": 14692,
          "scope": "entire invocation, including training controls, profiling and evaluation",
          "includes_rejected_and_profiling_generations": true
        },
        "protocol": {
          "test_opened": false,
          "gold_in_student_generation": false,
          "train_examples": 8,
          "validation_examples": 4,
          "max_tokens": 768
        },
        "parameters_changed": true,
        "encoder": {
          "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct",
          "revision": "7ae557604adf67be50417f59c2c2f167def9a775",
          "verified_mirror": {
            "public_id": "Qwen/Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct",
            "revision": "7ae557604adf67be50417f59c2c2f167def9a775",
            "file_sha256": {
              "config.json": "18e18afcaccafade98daf13a54092927904649e1dd4eba8299ab717d5d94ff45",
              "generation_config.json": "e558847a8b4402616f1273797b015104dc266fe4b520056fca88823ba8f8ebe6",
              "merges.txt": "599bab54075088774b1733fde865d5bd747cbcc7a547c5bc12610e874e26f5e3",
              "model.safetensors": "fdf756fa7fcbe7404d5c60e26bff1a0c8b8aa1f72ced49e7dd0210fe288fb7fe",
              "tokenizer.json": "c0382117ea329cdf097041132f6d735924b697924d6f6fc3945713e96ce87539",
              "tokenizer_config.json": "5b5d4f65d0acd3b2d56a35b56d374a36cbc1c8fa5cf3b3febbbfabf22f359583",
              "vocab.json": "ca10d7e9fb3ed18575dd1e277a2579c16d108e32f27439684afa0e10b1440910"
            }
          }
        },
        "encoder_frozen": true,
        "reasoner_frozen": true,
        "gate": {
          "training_bce": [
            0.6963445544242859,
            0.6618145108222961,
            0.6150948405265808,
            0.5792409777641296,
            0.5468487739562988,
            0.5094649791717529,
            0.47871750593185425,
            0.45303353667259216,
            0.4244154691696167,
            0.4004548192024231,
            0.3789491653442383,
            0.35493096709251404,
            0.3336018919944763,
            0.31281501054763794,
            0.29024767875671387,
            0.2698737680912018,
            0.2501712739467621,
            0.23023369908332825,
            0.21286551654338837,
            0.1962757557630539
          ],
          "training_cases": 24,
          "calibration_cases": 8,
          "calibration_temperature": 1.0,
          "training_classes": [
            0.0,
            1.0
          ],
          "threshold": 0.4,
          "calibration_split": "disjoint final quarter of train prompts; not validation"
        },
        "position_informative_groups": 0,
        "training_rollout_audits": [
          {
            "training_row": 0,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 187,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              59,
              84,
              120,
              162
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 0,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 186,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              24,
              43,
              119,
              158
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 0,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 193,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 8,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              29,
              64,
              99,
              116,
              128,
              153,
              168,
              186
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 0,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 170,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              29,
              90,
              103,
              147
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 1,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 286,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              35,
              142,
              261
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 1,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 175,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              23,
              83,
              153
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 1,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 277,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              35,
              82,
              253
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 1,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 208,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 8,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              31,
              83,
              118,
              148,
              165,
              170,
              186,
              196
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 2,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 294,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 6,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              47,
              105,
              162,
              192,
              241,
              284
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 2,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 265,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 5,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              46,
              105,
              159,
              199,
              243
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 2,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 365,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 12,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              20,
              107,
              137,
              169,
              191,
              203,
              220,
              234,
              255,
              295,
              317,
              353
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 2,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 261,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 6,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              54,
              81,
              118,
              158,
              192,
              241
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 3,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 215,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 5,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              28,
              59,
              113,
              171,
              189
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 3,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 196,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              53,
              88,
              144,
              178
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 3,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 224,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 9,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              44,
              63,
              80,
              99,
              136,
              156,
              182,
              202,
              213
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 3,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 184,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              83,
              125,
              162
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 4,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 201,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              47,
              99,
              177
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 4,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 208,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              25,
              81,
              124,
              184
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 4,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 250,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 5,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              24,
              39,
              96,
              147,
              224
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 4,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 256,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 3,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              21,
              156,
              232
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 5,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 246,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              24,
              89,
              154,
              222
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 5,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 242,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              32,
              101,
              156,
              212
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 5,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 228,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 5,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              63,
              101,
              138,
              195,
              217
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 5,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 260,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 5,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              30,
              95,
              161,
              226,
              249
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 6,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 248,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 8,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              29,
              42,
              67,
              101,
              130,
              166,
              181,
              225
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 6,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 195,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              28,
              76,
              125,
              171
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 6,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 255,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 6,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              30,
              84,
              123,
              157,
              189,
              228
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 6,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 1.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 242,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 4,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              44,
              113,
              164,
              220
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": false
          },
          {
            "training_row": 7,
            "response_index": 0,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 260,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 8,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              34,
              78,
              91,
              118,
              156,
              173,
              224,
              240
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 7,
            "response_index": 1,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 310,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 6,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              28,
              83,
              174,
              216,
              249,
              281
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 7,
            "response_index": 2,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 314,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 6,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              43,
              99,
              134,
              167,
              228,
              296
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          },
          {
            "training_row": 7,
            "response_index": 3,
            "correctness": 0.0,
            "truncated": false,
            "response_tokens": 261,
            "boxed_answer_detected": true,
            "paragraph_cut_count": 8,
            "paragraph_cut_indices": [
              28,
              91,
              105,
              133,
              164,
              181,
              225,
              242
            ],
            "eligible_for_position": true
          }
        ],
        "paragraph_boundary_protocol": "decoded-character-boundaries-to-original-token-prefix-v1",
        "execution_status": "failed-no-rescue-signal",
        "generation_budget_controls": [
          {
            "method_generations": 2,
            "base_generations": 4,
            "method_generated_tokens": 753,
            "base_generated_tokens": 1451,
            "maximum_response_token_allowance": 3072
          },
          {
            "method_generations": 2,
            "base_generations": 4,
            "method_generated_tokens": 468,
            "base_generated_tokens": 940,
            "maximum_response_token_allowance": 3072
          },
          {
            "method_generations": 2,
            "base_generations": 4,
            "method_generated_tokens": 706,
            "base_generated_tokens": 1395,
            "maximum_response_token_allowance": 3072
          },
          {
            "method_generations": 2,
            "base_generations": 4,
            "method_generated_tokens": 463,
            "base_generated_tokens": 987,
            "maximum_response_token_allowance": 3072
          }
        ],
        "limitations": [
          "Qwen2.5 frozen 0.5B encoder/7B reasoner and tiny GSM8K replace original Qwen3 and DAPO.",
          "Only learned gate controls inference; correctness labels are never visible to gate/cut policy.",
          "Zero rescue advantages and one-class gate labels remain visible and are not capability evidence.",
          "Matched maximum generations and token allowance do not imply equal actual runtime."
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "execution_checks": {
    "mechanism_passed": false,
    "execution_complete": true,
    "execution_status": "failed-no-rescue-signal",
    "gate_epochs": 20,
    "nonzero_rescue_groups": 0,
    "actual_position_optimizer_calls": 2,
    "entropy_only_position_updates": 2,
    "assessment_semantics": "single shared assessment AFTER head training, frozen reasoner control vs intervention",
    "parameters_changed_is_not_rescue_validation": true,
    "measured_cost": {
      "generation_calls": {
        "frozen_reasoner_training": 8,
        "position_rescue_training": 6,
        "evaluation_originals": 4,
        "matched_base_extra": 4
      },
      "generated_tokens": {
        "frozen_reasoner_training": 7662,
        "position_rescue_training": 1298,
        "evaluation_originals": 2390,
        "matched_base_extra": 2383
      },
      "scored_response_tokens": {},
      "frozen_encoder_forward_calls": 40,
      "frozen_encoder_input_tokens_including_prompt": 14692,
      "scope": "entire invocation, including training controls, profiling and evaluation",
      "includes_rejected_and_profiling_generations": true
    },
    "invocation_elapsed_seconds": 153.9949364028871,
    "configured_wall_cap_seconds": 900,
    "return_code": 1
  },
  "aggregate_metrics": {
    "frozen_reasoner_control.avg_accuracy": {
      "mean": 0.6875,
      "std": 0.0,
      "n": 1
    },
    "frozen_reasoner_control.pass_rate": {
      "mean": 1.0,
      "std": 0.0,
      "n": 1
    },
    "trained_intervention.avg_accuracy": {
      "mean": 0.625,
      "std": 0.0,
      "n": 1
    },
    "trained_intervention.pass_rate": {
      "mean": 0.75,
      "std": 0.0,
      "n": 1
    }
  }
}