{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "method": "smrc-pmrc",
  "seed": 42,
  "diagnostic_only": true,
  "evaluation_tier": "l1_mechanism",
  "evolve_eligible": false,
  "device": "cpu",
  "accelerator": "CPU",
  "elapsed_seconds": 1.599120541010052,
  "dataset": "paper-appendix-E.1.1-quadratic + seeded-small-MLP-regression",
  "dataset_revision": "arxiv:2610.19844v1:appendix-E.1.1:equation-30",
  "dataset_source": "https://arxiv.org/html/2610.19844v1#A5.SS1.SSS1",
  "host_reference": "NumPy FP64 SVD oracle and complete-QR protocol construction; torch CUDA kernels tested independently",
  "checkpoint_revision": "none; deterministic matrices and randomly initialized MLP",
  "public_protocol_sha256": "ffcc43947adef1dad30b4bbae2a46b57ddbc4f5293a2e69b1fc1934777218232",
  "budget": {
    "steps_per_arm": 80,
    "mlp_steps_per_arm": 80,
    "arms": 6,
    "max_seconds": 120
  },
  "numeric_controls": {
    "smrc_full_rank_max_abs_error": 1.3877787807814457e-17,
    "smrc_boundary_max_abs_error": 0,
    "smrc_state_resume_max_abs_error": 0,
    "pmrc_full_rank_max_abs_error": 1.3877787807814457e-16,
    "pmrc_boundary_max_abs_error": 0,
    "pmrc_state_resume_max_abs_error": 0
  },
  "low_precision_controls": {
    "smrc_fp16": {
      "updates": 6,
      "parameter_changed": true,
      "state_dtype": "float32",
      "max_abs_error_to_fp32": 3.458932042121887e-05,
      "comparison_atol": 0.0002,
      "state_resume_max_abs_error": 0,
      "state_restore_exact": true
    },
    "pmrc_practical_fp16": {
      "updates": 6,
      "parameter_changed": true,
      "state_dtype": "float32",
      "max_abs_error_to_fp32": 5.694106221199036e-06,
      "comparison_atol": 0.0002,
      "state_resume_max_abs_error": 0,
      "state_restore_exact": true
    },
    "smrc_bf16": {
      "updates": 6,
      "parameter_changed": true,
      "state_dtype": "float32",
      "max_abs_error_to_fp32": 0.00018548592925071716,
      "comparison_atol": 0.002,
      "state_resume_max_abs_error": 0,
      "state_restore_exact": true
    },
    "pmrc_practical_bf16": {
      "updates": 6,
      "parameter_changed": true,
      "state_dtype": "float32",
      "max_abs_error_to_fp32": 6.232969462871552e-05,
      "comparison_atol": 0.002,
      "state_resume_max_abs_error": 0,
      "state_restore_exact": true
    }
  },
  "paper_quadratic": {
    "smrc": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 0.47755969454596114,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 76,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "pmrc": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 3.3183929960789103,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 76,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "pmrc_practical": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 3.577340530429617,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 76,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "full_ema_sgd": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 0.22104417414557112,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 240,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "full_muon": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 3.3915845391218205,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 240,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "adamw": {
      "initial_true_gradient_norm": 7.615773105863909,
      "final_true_gradient_norm": 0.3793362773155953,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 480,
      "parameter_elements": 240,
      "updates": 80
    }
  },
  "small_mlp": {
    "smrc": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.1844657063484192,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 256,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "pmrc": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.053428955376148224,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 256,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "pmrc_practical": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.0747310221195221,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 256,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "full_ema_sgd": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.1725236475467682,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 848,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "full_muon": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.01644427701830864,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 848,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    },
    "adamw": {
      "initial_validation_mse": 0.3499470353126526,
      "final_validation_mse": 0.017611343413591385,
      "optimizer_state_elements": 1616,
      "parameter_elements": 808,
      "updates": 80
    }
  },
  "full_experiment": {
    "status": "not_reproduced_high_cost",
    "review_status": "done",
    "reason": "C4 60M–1.3B, 1.162B–26.84B tokens / multi-GPU pretraining and 7B–8B SFT omitted"
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Fixed tiny diagnostic hyperparameters, not the paper grid search or downstream comparison",
    "Synthetic real parameter updates only; not WikiText/C4 capability or wall-clock speed evidence",
    "Practical QR uses torch.linalg.qr, not authors' SCQR performance kernel",
    "No distributed state, AMP scaler/graph capture or torch.compile certification"
  ],
  "adapter_key": "smrc-pmrc",
  "manifest_ref": "reproduction:smrc-pmrc",
  "measured_locally": true,
  "seeds": [
    42
  ],
  "evaluation_protocol": {
    "tier": "l1_mechanism",
    "seeds": [
      42
    ],
    "formal_comparison": false,
    "claim_policy": "single-seed component diagnostic; not a stable capability comparison"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "artifact_path": "docs/reproductions/2610.19844-smrc-pmrc/metrics/cpu-seed42.json",
    "dataset_fingerprint": "ffcc43947adef1dad30b4bbae2a46b57ddbc4f5293a2e69b1fc1934777218232",
    "code_state": "CPU run from the implementation working tree; exact source hashes below",
    "source_sha256": {
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/smrc_pmrc/optim.py": "fa29076e8ff1dbd96fd432bc7b5d1554540831abf7801865a8c16c09d5e6ef8e",
      "src/auto_research/reproductions/smrc_pmrc/experiment.py": "2ed4d8c247d48961e3f8480273a7d8f493c46a20c847d6aded7373bd1f7cd76f",
      "scripts/run_smrc_pmrc.py": "7405d248fbbb7018301ab7559f2ef14ea6aed2588b862e9541d1e3a90afc54b8"
    }
  }
}