2026-10-15 review delivery record¶
Delivered in one MR #203. Review cutoff: 2026-10-15, through 15:39:55 China time. See scope and per-item decisions.
Completed scope¶
- Closed eight receipts across four tracks and two channels. The capped LLM query was completed by a real October-specific follow-up, without rewriting its original limits.
- Deduplicated 3,742 retrieved identities plus two official non-arXiv identities. Separately counted 794 newly registered first publications in the window, 1,320 historical/overlap entries, and 1,628 existing records.
- Closed 383 high-cost items as not reproduced, review DONE, with no retry or automatic implementation/Evolve. Fourteen affordable candidates were not implemented in this batch.
- Bounded official records: Google 412, Meta 144, DeepMind 265, and 18 new detail routes. Archived 37 source exceptions without blocking.
- Separately reviewed 11 existing paper versions, retaining the Dice Roll correction and SPARK/old SpecRoll differences. Old evidence was not promoted.
- Added candidate-level one-to-one validation of source exceptions and clarified historical/cost version baselines to avoid duplicate queuing.
Verification and limits¶
These are completed local checks in that delivery, not pending CI:
| Check | Local result |
|---|---|
| Source exceptions and cutoff regressions | 37 passed |
| Frozen receipts, counts, cost, and version regressions | 7 passed |
| Strict coverage including eight pending-artifact reconciliations | Passed |
| Compilation and Ruff | Passed |
| Fidelity inventory and paper-spec checks | Passed; inventory is not a semantic fidelity certificate |
| README sync and manifest/catalog/dashboard generation | Passed with no unexpected generated changes |
| 811 metric schemas and platform audit | Passed; metrics unchanged |
| Independent implementation reconciliation | None of the 14 accepted items entered the catalog or counted as implemented |
| Existing GPU receipt format | Passed; no new GPU runs or CUDA implementation |
| CLI manifest export | Passed; no new implementation |
| Strict documentation build and rendered register | Passed |
The full suite and minimal install are separate required CI checks on the MR check page. Failure is not delivery completion. GitHub Pages deploy is skipped for PRs by design. This batch did not merge or deploy without authorization.
Original excerpts, query receipts, and failures remain in reviewable caches; committed receipts remove duplicate abstracts. No weights or training data were downloaded. Remove generated site files and reproducible check caches after acceptance, not existing experiments, public data/weights, or active work directories.